Holding the Accountability Problem Accountable: Response Mechanisms to Counter-Majoritarian Decisions

  • Dave Bridge Baylor University

Abstract

If the Supreme Court rules against the wishes of the majority, how can that majority respond?  I argue that while federal judges will never stand for election, majorities can employ various response mechanisms to counter-majoritarian decisions.  I draw out observable expectations for inter-branch, local, and electoral responses.  I then test these expectations in cases from the “mature” New Deal—communism, school prayer, busing, and abortion—showing the range of effective results achieved by anti-Court majorities.  Given these results, I conclude that there is no “accountability problem”; there is just a narrow definition of accountability.

Author Biography

Dave Bridge, Baylor University

Assistant Professor

Baylor University

References

Ackerman, Bruce. 2005. The Failure of the Founding Fathers: Jefferson, Marshall, and the Rise of Presidential Democracy. Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674020054

Barnes, Jeb. 2007. "Bringing the Courts Back In: Interbranch Perspectives on the Role of Courts in American Politics and Policy Making." Annual Review of Political Science 10: 25–43. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.polisci.10.080505.101210

Barnes, Jeb. 2003. "Congressional Compromise on Election Reform: A Look Forward and Backward." In After 2000: The Politics of Election Reform, ed. Ann N. Crigler, Marion R. Just, and Edward J. McCaffery, 117–132. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Beck, Glenn. 2008. "Frightening Obama." 27 October 2008. glennbeck.com.

Bickel, Alexander M. 1962. The Least Dangerous Branch: The Supreme Court at the Bar of Politics. New York: Bobs-Merrill Co.

Blake, Judith. 1977. "The Supreme Court's Abortion Decisions and Public Opinion in the United States." Population and Development Review 3: 50. https://doi.org/10.2307/1971759

Bork, Robert H. 1996. Slouching Towards Gomorrah: Modern Liberalism and American Decline. New York: Regan Books.

Buchanan, Patrick. 1972. "Assault Strategy." Memorandum to John Mitchell. 6 June 1972.

Buchanan, Patrick. 1971. "The Muskie Watch." Memorandum for the President. 24 March 1971.

Clark, Tom S. 2010. The Limits of Judicial Independence. New York: Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511761867

Congressional Record, 1973.

Congressional Record, 1962.

Congressional Record, 1958.

Cook, Daniel M., and Andrew J. Polsky. 2005. "Political Time Reconsidered: Unbuilding and Rebuilding the State under the Reagan Administration." American Politics Research 33: 577–605. https://doi.org/10.1177/1532673X04270520

Crockett, David A. 2002. The Opposition Presidency: Leadership and the Constraints of History. College Station, TX: Texas A&M University Press.

Dahl, Robert A. 2003. How Democratic is the American Constitution? New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

Dahl, Robert A. 1957. "Decision-Making in a Democracy: The Supreme Court as a National Policy-Maker." Journal of Public Law 6: 293.

Direnfield, Bruce J. 2007. The Battle over School Prayer: How Engel v. Vitale Changed America. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas.

"Dividing the Democrats." 1971. Memorandum to the Attorney General H.R. Haldeman. 5 October 1971.

Dowd, Maureen. 2012. "Men in Black." 3 April 2012. nytimes.com.

Dolbeare, Kenneth M., and Phillip E. Hammond. 1971. The School Prayer Decisions From Court Policy to Local Practice. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Engel, Stephen. 2011. American Politicians Confront the Courts: Opposition Politics and Changing Responses to Judicial Power. New York: Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511994890

Ely, John Hart. 1981. Democracy and Distrust: A Theory of Judicial Review. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Ford, Gerald. "The President's News Conference." 9 October 1974. americanpresidency.org.

Friedman, Barry. 2002. "The Birth of an Academic Obsession: The History of the Countermajoritarian Difficulty, Part Five." Yale Law Journal 112: 153–259. https://doi.org/10.2307/1562239

Gallup. 1963. "The Gallup Poll."

Gallup. 1971. "The Gallup Poll."

Gillman, Howard. 2006. "Regime Politics, Jurisprudential Regimes, and Unenumerated Rights." University of Pennsylvania Journal of Constitutional Law 9: 107–119.

Gillman, Howard. 2002. "How Political Parties Can use the Courts to Advance Their Agendas: Federal Courts in the United States, 1875–1891." American Political Science Review 96: 511–524. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055402000291

Gottfried, Paul. 1992. The Conservative Movement. Twayne Publishers.

Graber, Mark A. 2008a. "The Countermajoritarian Difficulty: From Congress to the Courts to Constitutional Order." Annual Reviews in Law and Social Science 4: 361. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.lawsocsci.4.110707.172404

Graber, Mark A. 2008b. "Regime Politics and the Countermajoritarian Problem." Balkinization Blog. balkin.blogspot.com.

Graber, Mark A. 2005. "Constructing Judicial Review." Annual Review of Political Science 8: 446. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.polisci.8.082103.104905

Graber, Mark A. 1993. "The Nonmajoritarian Difficulty: Legislative Deference to the Judiciary." Studies in American Political Development 7: 35–73. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0898588X00000687

Henshaw, Stanley K., Jacqueline Darroch Forrest, and Ellen Blaine. 1984. "Abortion Services in the United States, 1981 and 1982." Family Planning Perspectives 17: 90–96. https://doi.org/10.2307/2135271

Hillygus, D. Sunshine, and Todd G. Shields. 2008. The Persuadable Voter: Wedge Issues in Presidential Campaigns. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400831593

Kernell, Samuel. 2006. Going Public. Washington, DC: CQ Press. Klarman, Michael. "Rethinking the Civil Rights and Civil Liberties Revolutions." Virginia Law Review 82: 1–67.

K'Meyer, Tracy Elaine. 2013. From Brown to Meredity: The Long Struggle for School Desegregation in Louisville, Kentuck, 1954–2007. Chapel Hill, NC: The University of North Carolina Press.

Lemieux, Scott E., and David J. Watkins. 2009. "Beyond the 'Countermajoritarian Difficulty': lessons from Contemporary Democratic Theory." Polity 41: 30–62. https://doi.org/10.1057/pol.2008.25

Levinson, Sanford. 2008. Our Undemocratic Constitution. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lovell, George. 2003. Legislative Deferrals: Statutory Ambiguity, Judicial Power, and American Democracy. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Mason, Robert. 2004. Richard Nixon and the Quest for a New Majority. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.

"Mayor Asks Federal Help in Boston School Dispute." The Bulletin. 10 October 1974. news.google.com.

McMahon, Kevin J. 2004. Reconsidering Roosevelt on Race: How the Presidency Paved the Road to Brown. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Metcalf, George R. 1983. From Little Rock to Boston: The History of School Desegregation. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.

Miles, Michael W. 1980. The Odyssey of the American Right. New York: Oxford University Press.

Nash, George H. 1976. The Conservative Intellectual Movement in America Since 1945. New York: Basic Books.

National Opinion Research Center, 1954. "The Communism, Conformity, and Civil Liberties Study."

Newman, Roger K. 2001. "The Warren Court and American Politics: An Impressionistic Appreciation." Constitutional Commentary 18: 661–698.

Nichols, Curt, Dave Bridge, and Adam Carrington. 2014. "Court-Curbing via Attempt to Amend the Constitution: An Update of Congressional Attacks on the Supreme Court from 1955–1984." Justice Systems Journal: 1–13.

Nixon, Richard. 1972a. "The President's News Conference." 22 June 1972. americanpresidency.org.

Nixon, Richard. 1972b. "Remarks and Question-and-Answer Session." 30 April 1972. americanpresidency.org.

Nixon, Richard 1972c. "The President's News Conference." 5 October 1972. americanpresidency.org.

Nixon, Richard. 1971. "Statement about the Busing of Schoolchildren." 3 August 1971. americanpresidency.org.

Obama, Barack. 2012. "News Conference." 2 April 2012. americanpresidency.org.

Peretti, Terri Jennings. 1999. In Defense of a Political Court. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Phillips, Kevin P. 1972a. "School Busing and Public Opinion." The Bryan Times 4 March 1972.

Phillips, Kevin P. 1972b. "How Nixon Will Win." New York Times Magazine 6 August 1972: 8.

Powe, Jr. Lucas A. 2000. The Warren Court and American Politics. Cambridge, MA: The Kelknap Press of Harvard University Press.

Pratt, Robert A. 1992. The Color of Their Skin: Education and Race in Richmond, Virginia, 1954–89. Charlottesville, VA: University Press of Virginia.

"Republican Party Platform of 1972." americanpresidency.org.

"Republican Party Platform of 1976." americanpresidency.org.

Romney, Mitt. 2012. "Values: Abortion." nowcomment.com.

Rosenberg, Gerald N. 1992. "Judicial Independence and the Reality of Political Power." Review of Politics 54: 391. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0034670500018222

Rosenberg, Gerald N. 1991. The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change? Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Rouse, Frank. 1997. "Interview." Raleigh News & Observer 6 July 1997. sohp.org.

Ryan, John Barry, and Caitlin Milazzo. 2014. "The South, the Suburbs, and the Vatican Too: Explaining Partisan Change Among Catholics." Political Behavior.

Scalia, Antonin. 1998. A Matter of Interpretation: Federal Courts and the Law. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Schick, Allen. 1982. "How the Budget Was Won and Lost." In President and Congress: Assessing Reagan's First Year, ed. Norman J. Ornstein, Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research.

Segretti, Donald H. 1973. "Testimony before U.S. Senate Select Committee on Presidential Campaign Activities." 3 October 1973.

Skowronek, Stephen. 2011. Presidential Leadership in Political Time: Reprise and Reappraisal. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas.

Taylor, Steven J. L. 1998. Desegregation in Boston and Buffalo: The Influence of Local Leaders. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.

Theoharis, Jeanne F. 2001. "'We Saved the City': Black Struggles for Educational Equality in Boston, 1960–1976." Radical History Review. 81: 61–93. https://doi.org/10.1215/01636545-2001-81-61

Tushnet, Mark V. 1993. The Warren Court in Historical and Political Perspective. Charlottesville, VA: The University of Virginia Press.

Warren, Earl. 1977. The Memoirs of Chief Justice Earl Warren. New York: Doubleday.

Whittington, Keith E. 2005. "'Interpose Your Friendly Hand': Political Supports for the Exercise of Judicial Review by the United States Supreme Court." American Political Science Review 99: 1–14. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055405051890

Williams, Daniel K. 2010. God's Own Party: The Making of the Christian Right (Oxford: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195340846.001.0001

Woods, Jeff. 2004. Black Struggle, Red Scare: Segregation and Anti-Communism in the South, 1948–1968. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State Press.

Published
2016-12-04
Section
Articles